Copyright 1990 Don Benish
CONCLUSIONSNow we can solve our equation by plugging in the various numbers and probabilities that we have derived. N=800 billion x 0.25 x 0.01 x 0.0001 x 0.00002 x 0.9 x 0.05 =0.18 We know that this equation must be at least one since we know that we exist. I have attempted throughout to use optimistic but realistic numbers. Yet we derive a solution that is six times smaller than we know that it must be. Many people might quibble with the numbers, but logical arguments will serve mostly to lower the numbers, not raise them. I challenge those who disagree with my conclusions to do their own scientific calculations and present their detailed analysis for critical discussion. Many of the proponents of SETI use downright silly numbers in their version of the equation to arrive at their desired solution. In his focal point essay in 'Sky and Telescope'(Dec 1989), radio astronomer Gerritt Vershurr called SETI a technological search for God. One would have to have such blind faith as religion to believe the numbers bandied around. Soon we may know more about the true nature of our galaxy. As I write this, the Hubble Space Telescope sits on the launch pad awaiting liftoff. But at best, we might massage the first two terms of the equation slightly. Many pro-SETI commentaries discuss how the feeling that we are truly alone displays a sort of arrogance about our place in nature. I don's see why we should be called arrogant when there is absolutely no evidence to the contrary. Scientists aren't arrogant when they dispute religion and magic. They simply see no scientific or logical reason to believe in it. As a final argument against the Search for Extra-Terrestrial Intelligence, consider how difficult it might be even were there some out there. Suppose we had a radio dish ten kilometers in diameter. If the aliens were pumping out three trillion watts of radio energy (a truly prodigious amount!), at one hundred light years distance, out radio dish would recieve 90 Attowatts (10E-18) of energy. This is assuming no appreciable power loss caused by the intervening inter-stellar medium. The likelihood of successfully recieving this miniscule amount and detecting it is slight. In spite of the numbers, I would still not be unduly surprised if someone might somehow prove to me that in fact one or two or even a half dozen technic societies exist. I could beleive in magic too with sufficient proof. But I would be totally flabbergasted if it was proved that there were more than that. I would have to then question our most cherished notions about the origin of life. Perhaps even the notion of the hand of God might then gain scientific credence. But until that time, I'll let the numbers speak for themselves. |