Copyright 1990 Don Benish

PLANETS WITH CONDITIONS SUITABLE FOR LIFE TO EMERGE

Here we arrive at a section in which astronomy has little or no standing. Given a planetary system, what is the likelihood of any planet in that system being capable of initiating and sustaining life. Note, this does not mean that it does initiate and sustain life. We merely require a planet that could do so.

First of all we must make some assumptions. What is life? In general, to be recognized as being alive, a thing must be capable of utilizing external subtances as raw materials and be able to replicate a close facsimile of itself. Its offspring (more than one) must also have this ability. This is truly an amazing feat, especially if we consider the origin of all life to be spontaneous in nature. In some manner, arbitrary, naturally occuring molecules come together to create a thing which is no longer random. (Science does not recognize the hand of God as a valid explanation for the creation of life. If it were scientifically shown that he did have a hand, then these calculations would be quite invalid. But that's a different subject.)

The second assumption is that this planet must have for a significant period both a liquid sphere and an electrically active atmosphere. We don't really know how long it took for life to be generated on earth. But at least three things would have to happen before the liquid sphere could disappear. First, the atmosphere would create the organic building blocks of life during electrical discharges. Second, the sea of organic soup would have to stir long enough for random processes to allow the lifeform to be created. This period of activity would need to last several million years at least. Lastly, the lifeform would have to evolve into a form that could survive outside of a liquid bio-sphere. This period will require no less than 100 million years. Of course the liquid sphere does not have to disappear. But we are searching for the worst case.

The need for an active atmosphere and a liquid biosphere come about from chemical kinetics. The energy input required to create the complex organic bits from simple molecules demand something on the order of a lightning flash to take place. Simple chemical kinetics is not up to the task of creating aldehydes and ethers and esters and acids from water and carbon dioxide. But liquid solutions are necessary for chemical reactions betweens complex molecules to take place. Spacing between molecules in a gas are usually too great for significant combinations to take place. Besides which, the heavier complex organic molecules tend to settle out anyway. The chemical kinetics of solids is far too slow and restricted for any life-forming activity to take place.

These assumptions put severe limits on where life can form. On planetary systems whose sun has a luminosity one half that of our sun, in order to recieve the same radiant energy, the planet would have to be closer to it than Mercury is to our sun. But the tidal interaction would then cause the rotational rate to slow down to such a rate that the difference between night and day temperature would be several hundred degrees. Far too wide a swing for any liquid biosphere to exist.

In fact our own liquid, water, is perhaps the only reasonable solvent to consider. It has about the widest range for the liquid state of any substance. Yet, it does not exist at all on Mercury or Venus except as trace vapor. On Mars, it exists as a vapor or a solid but not as a liquid. At the atmospheric pressure of Mars, there is no temperature at which water will exist as a stable liquid. Even if the radiation recieved by Mars could somehow be doubled, it could never have a liquid biosphere unless its atmospheric density were greatly increased.

On planets which are cold enough to condense another substance such as ammonia, the chemical activity would likely be too little to supply the random agitation needed to create life. As well, the liquid range of ammonia is only one half that of water. As a solvent itself, ammonia performs rather poorly.

On planets that are too hot for liquid water to exist, the most likely solvents are complex hydrocarbons such as alcohols, ketones, or aldehydes. Their solubility for other organic substances is usually quite low. They are also usually quite unstable and are not seen spontaneously in nature at those temperatures. Besides, their boiling points are not that much higher than water's and their liquid range is much less. There are no reasonable solvents for environments such as Venus or Mercury. Lead will melt on the surface of Venus, but it is hardly a suitable solvent.

Venus is a very interesting case. Given its distance from the sun, .75 A.U., it should be much cooler than it is. But it is believed that the increased radiation that it recieves, about double that of the Earth, was enough to prevent its supply of carbon dioxide (about the same as Earth's) from recombining with the rocks, as had happened on Earth. Thus its thich carbon dioxide atmosphere coupled with the small amount of water vapor (.1 to .4%) causes an enormous greenhouse effect. The small amount of water may stem from two causes. There may have been little hydrated material in what matter originally made up Venus or the water vapor was pushed into the upper atmosphere by the heavier carbon dioxide where it was dissociated by solar radiation into hydrogen and oxygen. The hydrogen was then blown away and the oxygen recombined with something else. Thus we see that only a very slight difference in radiation could account for the enormous differences that we see between Earth and Venus.

There are claims that at one time Mars had liquid water. This may be so, but evidence points to, at best, very little surface water which was very tenuous and ceased to exist when carbon dioxide fixation was complete. At that point, the atmospheric pressure was reduced to somewhere below 10 percent of Earth's. This loss of water most likely happened about the same period in Mar's history as carbon dioxide fixation became complete in Earth's history. This might have been alleviated somewhat if Mars had been larger. Its nitrogen would have been retained as Earth's was. Liquid water then could have been retained better although it still would have been subject to freeze out at the poles. This effect is completely understandable in light of Mar's much lower solar gift, less than half that of Earth. Its carbon dioxide fixation occured at a greater rate and went much further than on Earth. Also, carbon dioxide froze out at the extremely cold polar regions causing an greater drop in atmospheric pressure. The low atmospheric pressure has an even worse consequence than low water retention, for the formation of life. The atmosphere is the engine for generating the organic bits required to allow life to come about. Could there ever have been the vast lightning storms required in an atmosphere whose presuure was at most 10 percent of Earth's? Unlikely at best.

We come to several inescapable conclusions. The only reasonable solvent is water. The range of radiation recieved by a planet is extremely critical. If there is too little radiation, water may not form in the vast liquid seas required nor will a sufficiently dense atmosphere form. If there is too much radiation, then at best the water remains as a vapor only. At worst, a condition such as on Venus where most of the water is lost.

Thus, we see the narrow range of planets on which life arising spontaneously is possible. Doubtless, no planet of a K or M type main sequence star could do so. Any planet that recieved sufficient radiation would have a day of such length as to prevent the formation of liquid water. No A, B, or O type stars could have such planets. Such suns have typically short lifetimes with wildly erratic radiation profiles. Even were a planet perfectly situated at creation to recieve exactly the same solar gift as Earth, it wouldn't last long enough for life to evolve into anything. So this leaves us with the conclusion that only F and G type stars are reasonable candidates to have planets capable of initiating and sustaining life. The total number of these types of stars is probably less than one tenth of all types of stars.

If we just take these possible stars and decide the probability of them having a planet in our presumed acceptable radiation window, we should have our overall proportion.

On planets too small to retain nitrogen, they would have to be at least within 0.8 of Earth's radiation profile in order to retain enough carbon dioxide to keep the atmospheric pressure up. This is necessary for the formation of liquid water, but more importantly, for the atmospheric electrical activity required. They could not reasonably range past about 1.5 times Earth's solar gift or they would likely end up like Venus. Even on planets with a much lower proportion of carbon dioxide would still likely have a greenhouse effect that would eliminate liquid water. As well, they would likely experience a day that was too long.

On larger planets, like Earth or Venus, that can retain nitrogen, the maximum solar radiation would still be the same, but the minimum might decrease to as much as 0.5 of Earth's gift. But even here there are many variables that could leave the planet barren. The water may get frozen out in the poles and never form a liquid sea. This might be especially true if there is a high axial tilt. Or the level of carbon dioxide might be so low that there is not enough in the atmosphere for the lightning to work with to create the organic bits.

Even on Earth, there are many factors that had they occurred, might well have prevented our coming to be. Had the proportion of hydrates in the material Earth formed from been low, there may not have been enough water. Had the Earth formed with a slower spin, our day may have been too long to permit the formation of liquid water. Had our own axial tilt been greater, we would alternately experience extreme hot and extreme cold. This might not permit the maintenance of a continuous liquid sphere, but one that migrated with the season. This would surely not bode well for any proto-life.

I have surmized that only one in ten stars is of the proper type to have a planet that could initiate and sustain life as we believe it must be. Also we see that the extreme narrowness of the acceptable range of radiation intensity is such that few planets will randomly fall into that range. All things considered, I cannot believe that of all the stars with planetary systems, more than one in a hundred has such a planet.