Copyright 1990 Don Benish
WHAT IS THE PROBABILITY OF SUCH A PLANET ACTUALLY HAVING LIFEThis is truly a biological question. It digs into the heart of the arguments for the origin of life. On this planet, all life that we see, birds, animals, insects, fish, plants, fungi, bacteria, viruses, everything is descended from one ancestral thing. The vast disparity is a function of evolution changing offspring from the original thing into other forms. There is little question however of their relationship. If life was able to spring forth easily, then we should expect to see more than one such ancestor and several unrelated lines on Earth. We have not seen such lines. We believe that we understand the method by which life arose. We also believe that it is the only reasonable method for any life to arise elsewhere. First, we need a stable body of liquid which continuously exists for a very long time. As discussed in the previous section, the only reasonable liquid is water. Second we need a thick atmosphere that consists mostly of carbon dioxide. We need this because carbon is the only reasonable choice for a central molecule to base the molecules around. Silicon has often been suggested as an alternative, but it is actually quite unacceptable. Its chemical bond strength is such that silicon chains longer than about eight silicon atoms do not last because they break off under the whipping action of mild thermal activity. While silicon itself is fairly common in the form of silicon dioxide, silane, which is the silicon corollary of methane does not exist in nature. Thus, silicon based lifeforms are not practical alternatives to carbon based life. Nitrogen,which has a valence of three, tends to form a very strong bond with itself. Its triangular nature tends to prohibit formation of chains necessary to form complex molecules. Other proposed life basic elements are even less practical than silicon or nitrogen. This thick atmosphere needs to be quite active, forming great electrical storms almost continuously for a period of at least millions of years. Only in this way can the carbon dioxide be converted into the necessary complex organic bits that eventually may come together to form life. Ironically enough, Earth is now utterly unsuitable for the formation of a new lifefrom. Our atmosphere is much too calm. The organic bit generator is turned off. The period of time that Earth was in a state capable of forming life was probably no more than some tens of millions of years. Before that, there was not enough water present. Afterwards, the skies had quieted to the point that the seas were not so filled with the organic bits as they had been. During this time, the Earth was warm. Not hot, certainly below 100 degrees celcius, but very warm. Probably between 20 and 80 degrees at all times. The organic bits that were formed in the lightning flashes fell into the vast seas of warm water. These seas were for the most part shallow. They had not existed long enough to form the buckling and lifting that have since formed the high continents and the deep ocean basins. The waters of today's oceans are probably too cold to have produced life, even if there were enough organic bits. The thermal agitation necessary to bang the organic bits together require that the water be warm. So the trillions and trillions of organic bits that fell into the soup spent their lives being banged around, knocking up against one another. By far, the most probable thing to happen to a given organic bit was for it to eventually to break back down into its basic components and be dissolved into the water. Eventually, the gases would evaporate back into the atmosphere and the cycle would start again. Some enormously few organic bits might actually suceed in banging into another bit and forming a bigger organic bit. The next most likely thing that would happen to this bigger bit is that it might be hit by another organic bit and be broken back into its component parts or even furhter into its component gases. Some extraordinarily few of these bigger bits might actually hit another bit and stick to it, making an even bigger bit. Again, the next most likely event that would happen to this new super bit is that it would break apart again. So we see that in order to construe the creation of life, several chains of extremely unlikely events must happen, one on top of the other. The end product of nearly all these chains is something created totally by random that is a very large, complex organic molecule. It has come about purely by random chance. We sit and wait to see what it does. AND IT DOES NOTHING!!! It is not life! Maybe once in every thousand years, in every cubic mile of seawater, we will see one molecule that is as complex as the simplest thing that we could call life. Yet it is not life. It cannot escape the law of random processes. It must eventually break down into its constituent bits. It cannot recreate itself. So we continue to look. For millions and millions of years we examine every drop of water on the Earth. We are looking for that one molecule that is no longer random. This molecule will have formed, completely at random, in such a way that with the collection of lesser organic bits that exist in its immediate vicinity, it can faithfully recreate a duplicate of itself, without destroying the original. What an amazing molecule this will be! We continue to look, and finally, AHA!!!!, we find it. It is in a small landlocked lake. The molecule floats around in the lake, attaching itself by some means, not necessarily chemical, to the various constituent bits that it needs. When it has all the correct bits in place, then voila', by some method it chemically unites the bits and creates a daughter. Now there are two of these non-random things. But wait! Is this the life that we are seeking? Hell and damn! No, it is not. Even though the lake covers a thousand square miles and contains two hundred cubic miles of water, it is just not big enough. There are not enough of the right constituent bits to serve. Maybe after twenty generations most of the needed bits are used up. The sky does not produce enough new ones to matter. Now, many of the daughters wander around fruitlessly, never finding the needed bits. Eventually, they break down again into their constituent bits. They die. Others may be able to derive a few more generations by cannibalizing these discarded bits and making new daughters. The lifeform reaches an equalibrium at some low number of individuals, perhaps a few million. In general, the lifeform is doomed. It does not consist of enough individuals for evolution to effectively function. It may hang on for a few years or a few thousand years. But it cannot endure. Once the lake dries up or the environment changes, the lifeform will die out. How many short-lived lifeforms came into being on Earth we can't say. Maybe many, maybe none. What we do know is that one lifeform beat all the odds. It came together in a sea big enough that it did not run out of the needed nutrients quickly. It had enough generations to start evolving into a form that was not dependent on random chance to find the needed organic bits. The evolutionary form was able to use more common, basic bits and make their own nutrients. (Chlorophyll-based organisms like plants are an example) This had to happen for life to continue. A purely cannibalistic lifeform could not endure. When one starts to examine the immense difficulties and near impossible occurences that must occur in order for a lifeform to come into existence, we are surely astounded that we exist. To hypothesize that life is common throughout the galaxy is to ignore what little evidence we have. While the existence of organic molecules of varying complexity is surely common, the existence of that one special type of molecule that was able to beat the odds is surely the rarest of the rare. As an optimistic guess, I might think that one in ten thousand viable planets might actually generate a sustained lifeform. There will be much argument of this figure, but I challenge any proponent of the life is common theory, to analyze the needed collection of highly improbable events and prove his thesis. |