Copyright 1990 Don Benish

WHAT IS THE PROBABILITY OF SUCH LIFE BEING INTELLIGENT?

Here is another judgement call. We have never observed another species that we call intelligent other than ourselves. The first thing that we must decide is what is intelligence. In general, intelligence is considered to be the ability to think or reason a problem through and arrive at a valid conclusion. Many activities of lower animals, that at first seem to be intelligent, when later analyzed, are seen to be automatic reactions to stimuli.The maze running ability of rats and other creatures stems from trial and error and subconscious memory of right and wrong paths. Instinctive actions such as nest building, although quite complex in nature, are simple patterns buried somewhere in the genetics of the creature.

Another concept of intelligence has been expressed as the ability to think consciously. One is thinking and is aware that it is thinking. This is likely a pre-requisite of logic and reasoning. In order to reason a problem through, one must be able to picture the problem in one's mind. More physical aspects are often false indications of intelligence. Often claimed as sure signs of intelligence are the ability to talk and build a fire. Neither of these are sure signs of an ability to reason. Fire is a no more complex concept than is nest building. Much of so-called talking consists of reactions to stimuli. 'I am here', 'Go away', 'I am hungry', are all responese to stimuli.

Of the millions of animals on the Earth, only man has shown al the characteristics of intelligence. Some people claim chimpanzees and dolphins are also intelligent. I do not doubt that chimpanzees in a laboratory environment show some slight evidence of conscious thought. But in wild settings, there is little evidence that intelligence plays any part in day to day activities. As far as intelligence in dolphins, there is little evidence of any sort to support a claim of conscious thought. In any case, it is hard to imagine building a radio telescope with one's nose.

I would think that if intelligence were easily acquired, then of the millions of species on the Earth there would be more obvious representatives than man alone. There are examples of extinct species, all close relatives of man, who showed signs of intelligence. Manufactured tools and cave drawings for instance. But for one reason or another they proved not to be viable. It is believed that as Cro-magnon man evolved along with Neanderthal man, his superior characteristics allowed him to force the Neanderthals out of the common niche and eventually into extinction. But why weren't there other species, occupying other very different niches, who also could have evolved into intelligent species?

Evolution is a random process that simply rewards the chance beneficial event by selectively passing it on to future generations. If a random event is even slightly detrimental, it will be rapidly eliminated from the gene pool. Thus, random events that may be building blocks to future beneficial changes, may still be selected against and eliminated because they have some trait that is immediately detrimental.

The features that are believed to have contributed to the intelligence of man could also have been detrimental as they were being developed. If the ancestors of man had not been forced out of the trees at some time, then the body and head shape as we know it would not have developed. Not enough is known about the actual workings or even the location of the development of man to be sure, but it is believed that at the crucial points where man's ancestors made a radical change in body and head form, radical changes in the environment dictated a high selection for upright and more intelligent beings. As such, man arose by a combination of fortuitous events that enabled a normally debilitating change to suddenly become beneficial. Had the environment changed without the accompanying mutation, our ancestors would likely have died off. Likewise, if the mutations had had occurred without the change in the environment, normal evolutionary pressures would had eliminated the changes.

To suppose that such a succession of unlikely combinations of occurrences is to be expected in every occurrence of life is quite naive. Not only must the life be able to form complex multi-cellular organisms, but it must be able to evolve rapidly into many different paths. If the environment does not change enough, the lifeform will not experience evolutionary pressures and will remain as simple creatures. If the environment changes too much, too fast, then the lifeform will die off because it cannot adapt.

Science fiction writers hypothesize about a whole plethora of physical types for intelligent beings. But when one analyzes the practicality of these types for an evolutionary path that will result in an intelligent being, few make any sense at all.

Once again we must assign a number to this phenomenon. I can't believe an optimistic analysis could claim that any more than one in fifty thousand lifeforms might some day evolve into an intelligent creature. Such a creature would possess the mental and physical faculties to change its environment and adapt it to suit its needs. Whether it would do so to the extreme of man is our next question.