Copyright 1990 Don Benish

WHAT IS THE PROBABILITY OF A TECHNIC CIVILIZATION?

This raises the question 'What motivates an intelligent being?'. Once it has achieved a level of civilization sufficient to satisfy its physical needs where will it stop? Is it bound to keep striving onward and upward?


Our own civilization has proceeded by fits and starts. In ages past the level and energy of civilization and culture has waxed and waned. Often, devastations by foreign barbarians had extinguished the rise of a high culture that might have achieved a technic society. At other times, progress was impeded by religious dogmas which refused new ideas and changes. Physical calamities have played a part in the downfall of some advanced societies. Also, many societies just lose the spark of advancement and decline through apathy.

I believe that human nature is such that progress was inevitable. Because of our warlike, agressive nature I believe that man will always find cause for struggle within its own species. We will always seek the upper hand. Competition will cause an unceasing quest for invention and progress. Some people decry competition as the root of all evil, but that is nonsense. Competition is an outgrowth of the evolutionary forces that made us. Without competition we would still be single cell organisms.

One prime result of agression is curiousity. Man's curiousity about his surroundings will insure a continuing quest for knowledge. We are constantly seeking to expose the mysteries of existence. To seek the answers to unsolved mysteries usually requires the development of new methods and sciences.

But, are these traits the rule for all evolving intelligent beings? Perhaps the evolution from lower animal to intelligent civilization happens all in one location. Tribalism and nationalism may never develop. Agressive behavior may never develop. The constant need to gain the upper hand may never develop. The lack of aggressive behavior would truly be expected if the being was purely herbivorous. In such a society, the pressure to create and invent would be greatly less than our own. How could a technic society possibly evolve in such a society?

I feel that the prime requirement in the development of a technic society is the development of curiousity. Will a being who is inately non-aggressive still be highly curious about his environment and strive to solve its mysteries? Why are we curious? Is it simply the challenge of finding the the answer? Does a non-aggressive being actively seek challenges? Quite often, the safest answer to many challenges is to flee from it. Yet, as aggressive beings, we often accept the challenge and strive to overcome it. If we were not aggressive beings, would we likely accept ridiculous risks just to find out an answer? Doubtful. There are certainly other aspects of curiousity besides challenge. How they relate to aggressiveness is not clear. I still feel that challenge is the prime motivation in the development of our technic society.

Now if we accept that the prime ingredient in the development of a technic society is the level of aggressiveness of the being, we must ask ourself what is the likelihood of an intelligent species evolving without aggressive tendencies.

Recall from a previous segment of this discussion wherein I expostulated on the need of a purely photosynthetic form developing. One who did not require scavenging of necessary organic bits, but rather made its own fromn more basic bits like carbon dioxide and water. The likelihood of such organisms themselves developing intelligence is nil since their needs for sunlight and water are hardly things that would bring about intelligence. Likewise, the world inhabited only by plants and plant-eating things would not likely develop intelligence either since the plant eating things merely have to slowly move around to find other plants to eat. There are no forces at work that require cunning or craft. Only in a world which contains all three types, plants, herbivores, and carnivores (omnivores are acceptable) can intelligence develop. We then see that this situation naturally introduces aggression into the equation.

As we observe herbivores and carnivores in a common setting, we can see two distinct levels of intelligence. That of the herbivore is required only to fight or flee predation. The carnivore must have much higher cunning since he must initiate the hostility. If we assume that the difference is such that only carnivores would be able to develop a technic society, we have only one question left. What is the ratio of intelligent beings that develop from herbivorous creatures to those that develop from carnivorous creatures? In this we should look at man. It is believed that a great part of man's development of intelligence came through his increasing use of tools. Far and away the most significant of his tools were weapons. weapons designed not for self protection, but for his own predations. Had man not been carnivorous would he likely have valued tools as much as he did? It is not likely. It is obvious that we owe a great deal of our intelligence to out carnivorous nature.

So what is the likelihood that an intelligent species will develop a technic society? I feel that the high level of aggressiveness required by most intelligent species will allow at least ninety percent of them to develop technic civilizations.